Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome to the Protein Production Technology International podcast. We explore the latest advancements in alternative proteins, from cultured meats to plant-based proteins. 0:11 We talk to experts and innovators who are working towards a more sustainable, efficient, and kind protein system. Join us as we dive into the exciting possibilities of the alternative protein industry. 0:25 Hello, everyone, and thanks for joining us for today's session, Beyond the Farm: Biomass Food Systems for a Resource-Scarce Future. 0:32 It's fantastic to see so many of you with us, especially given that it's summer holiday season in many parts of the world. 0:38 Now, whether you're a familiar face from previous sessions or this is your first time tuning in, a very warm welcome. 0:43 If you don't know anything about Protein Production Technology International, we're a dedicated hub for the alternative protein industry. 0:49 We bring together innovators, researchers, investors, and food leaders from across the value chain, from early R&D to full-scale commercialization. 0:57 We do that through our daily news coverage, weekly newsletters, quarterly B2B magazine, our podcasts, monthly webinars, and our international conferences and exhibitions. 1:06 And speaking of events, be sure to mark your calendar for the twenty-ninth and thirtieth of October when we'll be in Amsterdam for the Future of Protein Production twenty twenty-five. 1:15 With almost one hundred speakers already announced and the preliminary agenda now live, this will be our biggest and most international event yet. 1:22 The early bird rate runs out on the twelfth of September, so be quick to save yourself a few hundred euros off the full ticket price. 1:29 You can find all the details, including how to attend, exhibit, or maybe even sneak into the speaker lineup at www.futureofproteinproduction.com. Now, let's get on to today's topic. 1:40 We're here to talk about biomass-based food systems, how things like microalgae, fungi, and microbial fermentation could help us rethink how we produce protein. 1:49 Specifically, how we might start decoupling food production from land, soil, and fresh water, and what it's going to take to actually make that shift mainstream. 1:58 The reality is the way we produce food is under serious pressure. 2:01 We're dealing with climate volatility, water shortages, degraded soils, geopolitical instability, and all of that is revealing just how vulnerable our traditional agriculture systems really are. 2:11 But there is hope, and that's what today is all about. 2:14 We're seeing a new generation of food production platforms emerging from microalgae to microproteins that can offer scalable, nutritious solutions with far fewer inputs and a much smaller environmental output. 2:26 To discuss this, we've brought together a fantastic group of innovators, scientists, and strategists who are all pushing this frontier forward. 2:32 We'll be exploring the science, the business models, and the big systems changes we'll need to go from potential to plate. 2:39 Now, for everybody tuning in, just a quick reminder, we're hoping to have some time for your questions. Please use the Q&A tab on the right-hand side of your screen to submit them. 2:47 I'll do my best to either address them towards the end of the session or, if appropriate, during the discussion itself. 2:52 If at all possible, try to avoid posting your questions in the general chat, as there's a very good chance that I may miss them. 2:58 Before we get into the panel discussion, though, we're going to have a very quick presentation from our sponsor, Arborea, and Kali Chattakundu. So Kali, over to you. Thank you 3:14 very much, Nick, and good afternoon, everyone. If we could just have the slide deck on, please. Fantastic. So 3:28 Arborea, uh, what we do is that we convert carbon dioxide into food without needing any fertile land, and we do this through the industrial photosynthesis of microalgae. 3:43 So every minute, a forest area the size of eighteen football fields is lost due to climate change, and that is because of the demand that we have for fertile land. And that's not the only problem. 3:57 Our global freshwater demand will exceed our supply by forty percent by twenty-thirty. Most of the Earth's soil will be degraded by twenty-fifty. 4:07 And according to one study, we even carry the equivalent of five plastic caps full of microplastics in our brains already from the existing food system. Hence, we need to do something about this. 4:21 Arborea's solution captures and converts carbon dioxide from any industrial source. Involves no deforestation, uses minimal fresh water, no expensive feedstocks, no open ponds, no location constraint, 4:37 no food secu- food security issues, and no tariffs. And it does this through a technology called the Biosolar Leaf. 4:47 So rather like the human lungs, where we breathe in oxygen and breathe out carbon dioxide, the Biosolar Leaf does this in reverse. 4:57 It breathes in carbon dioxide and breathes out pure oxygen as by-product, and allowing the cultivation inside large tubes of photosynthetic microalgae 5:08 from which we can extract all kinds of ingredients, proteins, colors, lipids, bioactive nutrients in unlimited scale, all from carbon dioxide. We don't have an open pond system. This is completely contained. 5:25 We don't have an expensive internal photobioreactor systems. This is a very low CapEx system. It's very easy to scale up. 5:33 We have a fully working pilot facility in Lisbon, Portugal, and by the back end of next year, we'll have a full-scale factory up and running, all producing microalgae from which we can extract ingredients just from carbon dioxide and sunlight. 5:50 So it's really a question here. 5:52 We can capture carbon and get credits for, say, a hundred dollars a ton, or we could capture carbon and convert it to make ingredients worth well over five thousand dollars a ton.So this is an economic solution as much as anything else. 6:08 And effectively then, barren land anywhere in the world could become ultra-efficient farmland. Every two tons of carbon dioxide captured can turn into one ton of food. The carbon dioxide does not need to be pressurized. 6:21 It can be collected from any industrial source. 6:24 And effectively, say, therefore, a hundred-hectare patch of non-fertile land with carbon dioxide and sunlight can be producing ten thousand tons of pure nutritional food ingredients at low cost every single year. 6:41 But why microalgae? Well, three billion years ago, the atmosphere was all carbon dioxide or very largely carbon dioxide, and microalgae came along to consume that carbon dioxide and emit the oxygen that we breathe today. 6:56 So it's no wonder they're packed full of micronutrients because that's how life started. We're talking about multiple vitamins, minerals in a bioactive form. 7:06 We're talking about proteins with a complete amino acid profile and a high digestibility. Essential lipids, fibers, esse-- uh, unique carbohydrates, all present within these microalgae. 7:21 And the technology that Arborea has allows us to manufacture any one of the known different photosynthetic microalgae at large scale and at low cost. But we had to start somewhere. 7:37 So we started with one microalgae, a well-known one, spirulina, from which we can extract protein, natural colors, bioactive nutrient concentrates. The protein that we have, as you notice, it's not green. 7:52 It's a neutral taste and color, water-soluble, heat-stable, highly nutritious, and multifunctional. Foaming, gelling, emulsifying properties all in one natural product extracted from spirulina. 8:09 Here you can see how the solubility, even at up to eight percent, clear, nutritious protein dissolved in water. You can even make plant-based milk out of it, or you can use it to reduce sugar in delicious milk chocolate. 8:25 These are multifunctional ingredients all from nature. 8:31 Here you see the foaming ability of the protein on the far right-hand side, the brand name NovaProtein, and you can see how it has multifunctional properties inbuilt into the protein itself. 8:46 From the same biomass, you can also extract natural color systems, natural blue that has remarkable pH and heat stability, for example. 8:57 Or bioactive nutrients, and these are, uh, shown to be good in multiple studies around the world for both human health, animal health, pet health, even soil health in regenerating the soil microbiome. 9:14 Studies have been around the world in both nutritional journals, medical journals, food journals, all waiting for an enabling technology to allow the controlled synthesis of microalgae. 9:27 All of the things you see here are well-documented studies, well-conducted studies, all literally waiting for an enabling technology to, to actually enact on them. 9:39 And this could be in nutrition and health, cosmetics, agrochemicals, sports health, women's health, weight loss, pet health, all well-documented studies, all showing the potential of microalgae. 10:00 So here we have an example where real products can be made anywhere in the world. This plant-based milk that I mentioned earlier is made with a protein for the first time that did not require any barren... 10:12 any fertile land. A clean label product, tastes delicious, and it doesn't even curdle in your coffee. And that's just the beginning. 10:25 This is an enabling technology for all kinds of ingredients: essential fatty acid, personal care ingredients, pharmaceutical ingredients, agrochemicals. So our team, very different skills, all nationalities. 10:42 We have biochemists, biologists, chemists, engineers, food scientists from the very largest companies to innovative small companies all working together, but on one mission. 10:54 You see, by twenty-fifty, the world will need additional fertile land the size of Africa. But with this technology, we would need a land area just the size of Greater New York to feed the world. Thank you. 11:07 Over to you, Nick. Uh, Kale for that presentation, which I think has framed today's discussion perfectly. 11:21 Um, as we bring our other guests onto the screen, um, I'd like you all to very briefly introduce yourselves, just your name, job title, and company. 11:29 But I'd like, I'd like you all to answer a big-picture question to set the stage. 11:33 It's sometimes overlooked that the, the global food system produces more greenhouse, uh, gas emissions than the entire transportation sector. 11:40 And yet when it comes to climate action, food often takes a back seat to cars and energy. Um, so why do you think that is, and how do we bring food system transformation into the spotlight where it belongs? 11:51 Leland, I'm gonna start with you.Hi, everybody. Uh, very happy to be on this panel today. Uh, my name is Celine Chiv Deb. I am the chief scientific officer at Mista. 12:03 Uh, Mista is a food-forward ecosystem that was initiated over y- eight years ago by Givaudan, the flavor house. And the idea is to accelerate the pace of innovation in the food system to meet the needs of the futures. 12:14 We, we count about thirty active members, uh, ranging from very large food players like Danone, full disclosure, as well as Aborea on the, on the very innovative startups. 12:24 I personally have been involved with, uh, biomass fermentation for the last fifteen years on systems ranging from microalgae to bacteria and fungal. So your question is very good. 12:33 I mean, we, we tend to take agriculture for granted. It's been evolving alongside the human population, but it's reaching a breaking point, as Kelly was alluding to, and we can't hide anymore. 12:45 We have to really pay attention to it because of all the crisis that we've been talking about. So hopefully we can get a little bit ahead of the biggest crisis, so we're ready when they hit. Mm-hmm. 12:55 And I'll go to Charles next. Thanks, Nick. Uh, thanks all, and happy to be here. Uh, so I'm Charles. I'm the CFO of Planetary, a Swiss, uh, startup focused on biomass and precision fermentation. 13:11 And Nick, to your, to your question, uh, with regards to, uh, how do we bring the food system transformation, um, my humble and simple opinion is we just need to live up to the task that we're, uh, given, which is to come up with products which are functional, tasty, and at price parity if not below. 13:28 So once we've tackled those points, then I think it will somewhat become mechanical. Mm-hmm. And Jean-Philippe? Hi, everyone. Uh, yeah, Jean-Philippe Murphy from, uh, Imperial. 13:40 I'm working with the Basel Centre for Sustainable Protein and specifically focusing on scale-up and regulation. And yeah, I think it's a good question. 13:48 I think the reason why food is harder to transition than, say, energy or transportation, um, is because it's deeply personal. It's a deeply cultural thing. 13:58 You know, what, what electricity comes through the light, um, compared to what we put in our mouths has a very different feeling to it. 14:05 Um, so, so yeah, I think that's why we see bigger challenges, but I think we're making a lot of progress. So yeah. Thanks, Nick. Certainly. Uh, Karim? 14:13 Uh, Karim Krimoli, uh, director of single cell protein within DSM-Firmenich. And in answer to your question, uh, Nick, I, I think it's coming. However, we still need to tackle the issue of taste 14:27 and texture, and most importantly, cost, affordability. But otherwise, i-if you talk about carbon footprint, single cell proteins are there. If you talk about land use, it's there. Water use, it's there. 14:40 So it is only a matter of time. However, we do need partners. We do need collaboration along the value chain. It's not gonna be happening just by us pretending to disrupt the industry. We have to collaborate. 14:55 And finally, Roland. Hi, everyone. Thanks for inviting me. So I'm Roland Gouzy, uh, R&I manager, responsible of alternative protein innovation in Danone. 15:07 And to answer your question, I think that, uh, especially when we think about Danone, the dairy proteins are really still, in most of the cases, superior in, uh, nutrition, taste. 15:21 And I think even if we know that some new biomass, uh, or plant-based proteins are almost there, in some cases even matching, uh, the quality, nutritional quality and taste quality, I think, yeah, 15:36 we need really to work on the taste, as, uh, Karim said, and, uh, the nutritional values needs to be, uh, really, uh, or the same or even superior maybe in some cases. So we really need to work hard there. 15:51 We're gonna, uh, be talking about both of those, um, aspects a bit later on. Now that we've established the stakes, um, let's talk about biomass fermentation and microbial food systems. 15:59 Charles, um, I know in our prep calls you've described submerged biomass fermentation as a sort of crisis-proof system. Um, what makes it such a, a resilient and scalable food platform? Um, thanks, Nick. I think... 16:12 So I will speak for, for what I know and with a real focus on, on microprotein. But, um, and I think the same can be said for single cell protein and other biomass focus. 16:21 But i-in essence, uh, submerged microbial fermentation is just a very efficient process. Um, you're using microorganisms who tend to thrive and grow at accelerated speed when the condit-conditions are right. 16:34 So that includes good feedstock, the proper medium, and of course, the right bioprocess. 16:39 Um, I'm not aware of many other processes, um, which can turn, you know, grams, uh, or kilograms into tons of output and, and product into such a short period of time. 16:50 We're talking, you know, forty-eight to seventy-two hours for, for a single batch fermentation. 16:55 So, um, I just think it is, uh, from that perspective, it is a very resilient process, and it's also very resource efficient. Uh, little water is needed. Um, we have zero waste at all in, in the process. 17:07 The yields are high. Uh, we require effectively no land, um, though of course we do need the electricity and, and, and the infrastructure to, to get it done. So, um, in essence, that's, that's how I picture it. 17:20 I, I, I would think that in a day where soil are degraded and availability of feedstock is reduced, then I think this is one of, if not the best option out there to produce high quality, uh, bio-based ingredients in mega current. 17:34 Mm-hmm. 17:35 Celine, from your work with brands at Mista, um, do you think whole mass-- uh, sorry, whole biomass ingredients like, um, microproteins or algae offer a better nutritional and functional balance than isolates or, or precision fermentation, for instance? 17:50 Yeah, it's a, it's, it's a good question, and the answer is it depends. But usually, uh, if you consider a whole cell, as Kelly was saying, the microalgae were the first living cell really to proliferate on Earth. 18:01 They really need to be able to sustain themselves and multiply in any condition. 18:06 So they kind of carry-It's built in everything that the cell needs, from all the building blocks to vitamin and things that can fight off, uh, UV light and so on. So they are really, uh, nutritional bombs, most of them. 18:18 Some have more protein, some have more fat, some have more fiber, but they really have all the, the building blocks. In terms of functionality, I think, uh, Roland and Karim started to talk about it. 18:27 Um, some are highly functional, but they may just foam, some may gel. 18:31 Uh, they do sometime carry some negative, um, either colors or flavors that, uh, might be detrimental to some applications, but, uh, could be worked in others. So there, there's some work to be done there. 18:43 When you contrast them with other systems, either to grow plants and isolate them, uh, some benefits might be that you can, uh, do away with some beanie flavors, seasonability, use of pesticide, and so on. 18:55 And if you compare it to other methods of fermentation, like precision fermentation, you typically could go to some type of lower cost, uh, either CapEx and OpEx, because you don't need as much downstream processing, you have more flexibility of feedstock, et cetera. 19:10 So, um, so all in all, it, it shows really a lot of promise. 19:13 And I think, uh, as it was alluded to by, uh, by Charles, uh, they really have an opportunity to become a, a bulk low-cost nutrition basis as other workhorse of agriculture has been, which is not necessarily the case of isolate of precision fermentation at this point. 19:31 Mm-hmm. Um, Roland, how is, uh, Danone thinking about these next gen ingredients? What, what are the main barriers to incorporating biomass into large scale food portfolios, such as the one that you have? 19:44 So yes, uh, so I think that there is a, a lot... 19:49 I don't know if it's really a lot, but there are some players it, uh, I think, uh, mostly about startups that are providing, in some cases, uh, some really performant ingredients, but still, uh, 20:03 it's a small scale, and we need, uh, more facility to... facilities to scale up, for instance. 20:09 And actually, Danone is working, uh, hard on that, and we are building at this very moment a scale-up facility in France, in the city of Clermont-Ferrand. Uh, so this facility will help, uh... 20:24 I think in the beginning, the, the focus will be precision fermentation technologies, but not only. 20:30 And this sort of investment by big firms like Danone, uh, is really needed to help the small players to provide the volumes- Mm-hmm... and help us to, to implement this new ingredient into our portfolio. Mm-hmm. 20:46 Um, Kelly, uh, I know in our prep calls, you, uh, and in your presentation as well, and Karim's already touched on it, you emphasized the importance of performance. That's taste, texture, also shelf life, I guess. 20:55 How can we meet those expectations, um, without falling back into that whole ultra-processed, um, debate? 21:03 Yeah, it's a good, good, uh, good point, because we can't compromise on things like taste, texture, or, or shelf life. And the key thing is to really... 21:11 it's to use nature rather than to abuse it, 'cause the answer often is in na- in nature if we actually discover it and use it properly. Um, quite often when we... 21:22 our current processing techniques remove things like vitamins and minerals, uh, from the food, and then you're fortifying it with artificial vitamins and minerals afterwards to try and get it back. 21:32 But then the body recognizes that these are artificial. It doesn't digest them. 21:37 Whereas when you look at bioactive vitamins and bioactive minerals present in things like microalgae or other natural products, the cells do recognize them. So you, you, you don't need to over-process things. 21:48 You can actually deliver the, uh, the nutrition in, in a, in a good way to begin with. 21:53 And then functionally, a lot of, uh, ingredients that are, uh, that are in nature already, already have natural foaming or gelling or emulsifying properties if you know how to use them. 22:03 And so the protein that we make, for example, from, from microalgae already has this inbuilt. You don't need to process it further in order to get, to handle those properties. So the key is really to, um... 22:15 it's more about discovery and trial rather than over-processing something to try and get the functionality or the nutri- uh, uh, or trying to add back the nutrition that you've lost. Mm-hmm. 22:27 Let's, um, shift focus slightly to what drives real consumer adoption, because even the best sustainability story won't matter if the product doesn't meet expectations at the shelf. 22:36 Um, Karim, we've talked many times, a-and I know you're of the belief that we may have leaned too heavily into the alternative to meat narrative, um, without delivering enough on taste, texture, or cost. 22:46 W-what do you think we need to get right this time around? Yeah, I think it's one of the, uh, problems of startups and, and, and a new, uh, industry that we, we see ourselves as disruptors, so we go into disrupting, 23:04 and we think because we're disrupting and we've got something which is better than meat, i.e., the alternative protein, a consumer or a shopper should purchase. 23:12 But we missed out on the key signals of why a shopper purchases, which is cost, taste, and texture. So coming back to your question, you know, we gotta work on the taste, and particularly the aftertaste. 23:26 I, I bought burgers and chicken nuggets and et cetera for my kids, and yeah, the aftertaste is one that comes back to bite me, so to speak. So aftertaste is an important thing. 23:39 The other thing with regards to texture is that first bite. How does that first bite feel? And then how does the product actually go to the back of the palate? Does it crumble? 23:51 So you gotta, you gotta sort out mouth feel as well. And taste, texture, and I would say also cost. So single cell protein producers have to worry about cost and have to work on that. 24:02 But if you sort out taste, texture, and cost and try and get that meat-eating experienceThat the shopper or consumer normally is used to, we will then definitely get a higher than one percent of total meat sales in the USA, 'cause that's where we are today. 24:21 We're not touching the other consumers who are, by the way, wanting to reduce meat intake. So we've got some way to go. However, I have to say, I've seen some wonderful products out there on the market coming in too. 24:37 And as you probably know, Lidl and Aldi... Sorry, Lidl and also Albert Heijn have also, uh, launched a whole new series of products, which funny enough, are actually combining the alternative with the meat. 24:50 So you get a taste, you get the texture, and behold, you get the low carbon footprint and a better life cycle analysis. So I think we are-- we, we're moving in the right direction, but we've got a long way to go. Yeah. 25:03 I think that Ald... Sorry, that Aldi product or the Lidl product was sixty-forty split for meat and plant-based products. 25:09 Roland, um, are you seeing changes in how consumers, especially those focused on health and nutrition are, are thinking about proteins now? Yeah. So very nice questions, uh, question. 25:23 So you know that Danone, uh, has already in all the supermarkets, uh, in Europe, at least high protein versions of their dairy, uh, beverages like yogurts and so on. 25:35 We also have the Alpro and Silk high-protein, uh, alternative dairy products. 25:42 But, uh, this new type of ingredients, namely, uh, biomass proteins, are really, uh, have a really big potential in term of health benefits. 25:54 And, uh, the interesting part is that it's not fully studied, so the potential is, 25:59 is very, uh, high because we don't know yet exactly what every type of like a fungi or a bacteria, how it, uh, influence the, the, the health, our health. So I think- Mm-hmm. 26:13 Uh, for us, it's really a, a hot topic, very interesting to, to put, uh, all the players together and try to understand, uh, this aspect of the ingredient. Mm-hmm. 26:25 Celine, you, you have the advantage in that you work with quite a few startups. 26:28 What are the big new drivers of innovation in the food space, and, and, and how could biomass products stand out as not only better for you, um, but better for the planet as well? Yeah. 26:38 Uh, it's really, really interesting. Uh, uh, I'm often the pessimist, but I think there really are a couple of trends that are really, uh, leading to, uh, having the biomass product in the spotlight. 26:49 Uh, being in the US, there's a really, uh, in Europe too, uh, there's very strong, uh, awareness that is being brought by the new, uh, government, uh, on the Make America Healthy Again. 27:01 Uh, and it's really trying to, uh, point a finger to the synthetic dyes, to the ultra-processed food and, and all those things, and trying to go back to basics. 27:10 So there's, uh, really, uh, a, an interest to have less processed products and more natural. 27:16 In parallel, and I think it's also more pronounced in the US at this point, but, uh, it's all often spreads to the rest of the world, is the all epidemic of obesity and the promise of GLP-1 drugs. 27:27 Uh, I think I, I saw a staggering number. I think over ten percent of Americans already tried those GLP-1 drugs. 27:33 And what it really did is not only, uh, it prevents people from eating as much as they wanted, and so they really need to think about, uh, uh, dense nutrition, but they all... 27:43 it's also recasted the whole, uh, rationale around, "I can change my health with what I eat. I'm in control. Uh, I need more of what's good for me." 27:51 So I think all those elements really lend to nutrition density, uh, natural, minimally processed products. And again, as we discussed earlier, a biomass of product could really, uh, tick all those boxes. Mm-hmm. 28:05 I have a confession. So I'm actually, I'm actually using a GLP-1 at the moment. I've lost thirteen kilos in the past ten weeks, and it has changed the way I shop and eat. 28:15 Um, so definitely paying more attention to nutrition and, and proteins, et cetera. 28:19 Kelly, um, what's it going to take for mainstream consumers to see microbial proteins not just as substitutes, but as real upgrades, um, to conventional food? Absolutely. 28:29 I, I think Karim touched on it a bit earlier, actually. I mean, people eat the finished food, not the food ingredient. 28:36 So the key thing is that they need to start seeing food prototypes that look and taste familiar in both taste, texture, mouthfeel, et cetera. 28:45 So, uh, if it looks good, tastes good, if it's so good, in fact, that it's endorsed by sort of chefs and farmers and people as, uh, as great food products, finished food products, then I think, um, that's gonna start the change. 28:59 And, uh, really shout out to the MISTRA organization, Celine and Roland, because we've-- as a startup, we found it incredibly useful that we can collaborate, uh, within MISTRA as startups with large corporates to make such food prototypes. 29:13 Uh, the plant-based milk that I showed earlier, that was made from, um, startup to finish, um, in under three months, i- including the packaging, uh, within the MISTRA organization. So, uh, and that's the key to it. 29:26 People have gotta see, touch, and taste the finished food, really- Mm-hmm. And, and it's gotta meet their expectations. Mm-hmm. 29:33 Now let's, um, talk about how we actually scale these technologies and how to do it without hitting that infamous valley of death, um, for startups. 29:40 Um, Charles, Planetary has taken a very operationally, um, grounded path using existing infrastructure. You've got an approved strain, and you're focusing on B2B. What's the biggest benefit of that strategy? 29:53 Um, it's true. Uh, we effectively took every possible shortcut to, to get to, to market in, uh, what we hope is, is record time. I see not one, but two key benefits, uh, uh, in, in my opinion. 30:06 The first one is, uh, you know, we try to, uh, own our destiny. Uh, so no novel food approval. 30:13 We're using fusarium venatum, which is an approved strain.Uh, and that's a way for us to use a known product which has been approved by consumers globally. Um, known by big food, uh, big retailers as well. 30:26 So it was just a way for us to go with a valid and, and successful product from, from the get-go, even though, of course, we can work with a wider range of, of strains. 30:37 And the second, um, you know, advantage I see is just that, um, uh, trying to, to take that shortcut that I mentioned. 30:44 You know, scarcity is really the, the root or the source of innovation, so we came up with this notion of what we call symbiotic engineering concept, whereby instead of building a brownfield or greenfield plant for fermentation purposes, we actually, uh, siloed ourselves within an existing sugar mill in, in Switzerland with, uh, Schweitzer Sugar being our local partner. 31:05 Uh, and because we managed to do this from both an engineering perspective but also an operational one, uh, we have now decided to license that knowhow to sugar producers globally. 31:16 We're the only ones in the world running on sucrose specifically for mycoprotein. 31:20 So, uh, just being able to be, uh, uh, very lean in our approach has effectively enabled us to, uh, pick the right business plan and offer a real turnkey licensing solution to sugar producers globally. Mm-hmm. 31:35 Um, I can see we've got lots of questions coming in, so I'm gonna get to some of those in a moment. 31:39 Um, John Philippe, from your perspective at the Bezos Center at Imperial, um, where are the biggest choke points between promising biomass research and market-ready deployment? Thanks, Nick. 31:49 Um, I think, I think on that, some of them we've already touched on briefly, but regulation is a key one, um, for s- for sure. 31:57 Um, and where companies can take approaches like Charles, where you can use products which have already been on the market, and maybe you're taking new approaches to produce them, um, that really, really kind of eases the path to market. 32:09 In the UK, for example, we have one of the oldest, uh, mycoprotein producers in, in Quorn, um, and they use, um... 32:17 and companies then sometimes choose to use the same strain that, that Quorn have used, um, but might be producing it in, in new methods. 32:24 So, uh, regulation's a key bottleneck 'cause it's very hard to think about both your, your production method, but also align with what regulators in different jurisdictions are, um, are prioritizing. 32:35 Then another key, a key asset which also listening to Charles's response, um, relates to this is, is scale-up and infrastructure. 32:42 Um, so to produce this biomass at scale, you know, often, uh, traditionally you need steel, you need big fermenters, um, and that can be very costly. 32:51 So thinking innovatively about using potentially CDMOs, um, for us at Imperial, we potentially wanna also provide some of that infrastructure. 33:01 But, um, like, like Charles and other companies I've had in the, uh, biomass space, um, working with corporates, co-locating your facilities with, for example, um, sugar producers where, you know, you can, you can have, um, those benefits and be lean is, uh, is kind of optioned for some companies. 33:19 Um, I think then finally, and, and this kind of ties into what, um, some of the others have been saying, um, on, on for example, the MR model and so on, being able to, to put your products in for-- in front of corporates, being able to, um, to really get that insight into what, what the market wants and what, um, large food producers want, if they're gonna be your, your end customers, I think is, is also key. 33:43 So I think those are, those are some three key pillars that I would see as critical to enable those path to markets. Mm-hmm. 33:50 Um, Kareem, I, I know from previous conversations that I've had you-- with you that, um, time to market's often underestimated, especially for getting into major food brands. 33:58 But what can startups do to de-risk that journey? I would say two, uh, suggestions or recommendations on that front. One is technical, and that is product consistency. 34:12 It's one thing to have a product coming out of the bench scale or pilot. 34:16 It's something totally different to have a product consistently the same, physical and chemical, three hundred and sixty-five days a year, twenty-four/seven. That's what the food majors want, consistency and quality. 34:32 I think some startups underestimate that. It's quite a taking, and that's where they need a lot of expertise, particularly in the scale-up phase. That's one thing. 34:43 The second thing I notice, and I've suffered this myself and done the same thing, is a lot of us have bilateral engagements. An ingredient supplier with a food processor, an ingredient supplier with an FMCG. 34:59 However, what I would recommend is we need to engage in what I call value chain marketing, and that is your end user, the last mile to the mouth of the consumer, has to be in that first meeting. 35:12 So in this example, I would say you need an ingredient supplier, the food processor, either private label or, or branded, and your retailer. 35:22 So you get your retailer engaged in the workshop, what I call value chain marketing, so all the supply chain members are in the f- workshop at the beginning. 35:31 If you get the pull from the retailer, you know you've got an end user. 35:38 So the challenge is actually, I can get a food processor interested, but can I get my product to the mouth of the consumer, into the shopper's basket? That takes the last bit of the value chain. 35:50 And I think that's somehow we tend to forget about it, and it's something I have to say, I learned it the hard way during my time in Vera Maris. 35:58 We had to get the retailers on board to what we were doing, and I would encourage that. I call that value chain marketing. It's a harder, it's a harder, uh, thing to do, but 36:10 at least you then know your product will get to the mouth of the consumer. Uh-huh. That's, uh- So value chain mark-Yeah, that's the topic of a, a completely different webinar, I think, Karim. 36:22 I'll come back to you on that. Um, Celine, at Mista, you see a lot of companies scale too fast or even stall. Um, so in your opinion, what separates those who make the leap from those who don't? 36:32 So I-I don't wanna repeat a lot of good stuff that, uh, Karim and Jean, Jean-Philippe and Roland already mentioned, and Charles. But I think the first one is kind of, uh, 36:43 kind of really close to just stated, but you need to make sure that your product is good, and good means many things. Consistency, uh, is it, uh, is it at cost parity with the, the value you're delivering? 36:54 Does it solve someone's problem? 36:55 Because initially, uh, the food industry is, uh, resistant to changes, so they will change only if it helps them either make a problem-- a product better or solve the problem they currently have. 37:06 You also need to engage with the, the partners early all the way to the retailer tool, uh, onboard with you, Karim, about having the whole ecosystem value chain, uh, talking together. 37:16 Scaling is really a chicken and egg question because if you go to the no-no, any other big company, and you come with a, a new product, you don't have the scale. 37:24 So those big companies cannot use your product because you-- they can't even serve one SKU in one country. 37:31 Uh, but it's really hard to pro-- to build and get the capital to build a, a facility or to scale, um, before having customers. 37:38 So, uh, customer don't come because you don't have scale, and if you don't have, uh, scale, you can't have customers. So it's, it's really difficult. 37:46 Uh, Jean-Philippe mentioned that there are ways to be smart about it, uh, work with partners, uh, with CMOs. Uh, I really like the model you described, Charles. It's really interesting to license your technology. 37:57 Uh, but sometimes in the case of Arborea, Kelly has no choice because he's trying to demonstrate a brand-new system, so he has to just demonstrate and build his own, uh, facility. 38:09 Um, and finally, I think, uh, as part of, uh, engaging, uh, and animate the product, it's really important to create good product that tick all the boxes that can convince people along the whole value chain because scaling too early. 38:22 Mm-hmm. Uh, and I won't go into regulatory, but I think that goes hand to hand, uh, with, uh, being able to put a product on the market. Mm-hmm. I'm gonna take some questions now from the audience. 38:32 Um, Kelly, I think these first two will be for you. This is from Celi- Celia, sorry, Ferreira. Um, to make it soluble, um, did you need to, um, apply any special treatments? Uh, no. 38:43 Uh, we didn't have to, uh, do any hydrolysis or anything like that. Um, it's inherently, um, uh, soluble. 38:50 Now, there is, uh, very mild downstream processing from the microalgae, um, but it's very mild, and slight tweaks in that results in either more solubility and less foaming or more foaming and less solubility. 39:02 But, uh, no special chemical treatment or anything like that. Um, here's another one for you, Kelly. This is from Kartik Bajpai. 39:08 Uh, what material was used to produce this biosolar converter other than using bioconverters microalgae? Yeah. 39:15 So, um, so with the construction of the factory, it doesn't require large amounts of metal or glass or anything expensive like that. It's largely the bulk of it is actually recycled plastic. 39:26 Very special recycled plastic 'cause it's a breathing membrane that can breathe in that carbon dioxide and generate the microalgae. But, uh, in terms of material, uh, that-- essentially that's the basis of it. 39:37 It's a breathing polymer material. Mm-hmm. And it's o-outdoors, but an enclosed system. I'm not gonna sure-- I'm not too sure who's gonna answer this one, but it's from, um, uh, Juan Martinez. 39:48 I think he's from Solar Foods. How do the panelists think biomass food using more innovative processes with feedstocks such as CO2 or biogas? 39:56 So think companies like Solar Foods or Calysta will fare in the market compared to more traditional sources of single cell protein such as sugar-fed mycoprotein or microalgae. So I'm not sure who's gonna answer that one. 40:07 I'm gonna pick whoever puts- I, I think it's Kartik. Go on, Celine. I think you'd be, uh, you'd be, you'd be non-biased, impartial. Yeah. Uh, I, I did... 40:15 Full disclosure, I did work with Calysta using, uh, methane as a, as a, as a feedstock, and we've been working at, uh, Mista with many other gas fermentation company ranging from CO2 to others. I mean, in a way, 40:28 uh, we don't think about it that way, but, uh, Arborea system is also a gas fermentation system. But, uh, it's more like natural in people's mind because nobody's questioning that plants and microalgae breathe in CO2. 40:39 But, uh, most of us, uh, over gas fermentation platform do use, uh, bacteria, uh, as a, as a main organism. 40:47 And so, uh, it's kind of less direct for consumers to think of a bacteria as being a source of food, although we've been eating bacteria all along, uh, anyways. 40:56 Uh, those, I think, have a big promise in terms of carbon capture and being able to absolutely have zero connection to the agriculture. 41:06 They don't need any sugar input or anything, so it's really creating brand-new food from something that is a, a waste or a negative gas. 41:15 On the other hand, they all have to prove that their system works, so it's very capital intensive because they most of them need some, uh, very own fermenters and different s-shapes. 41:24 I mean, with a shout-out to String Bio in India, they seem to be able to use methane in a normal stirred tank and be able to use any CMO. 41:32 But so there's a lot of CapEx and proving the, the scale and, and, uh, and the other one is s-- not always, but sometimes the system do come with some hindrance in terms of, uh, taste profiles that can be metallic or some color. 41:46 So it might be limited to some, uh, to some applications that are not looking for a white, a pure white, uh, product. Mm-hmm. Uh, this one, uh, might be for Karim. Um, Karim said, this is from, uh, Marge Maishis. 41:59 Um, Karim said that Albert Heijn and Lidl have great new products, um, those hybrid products that we talked about. Why do retail and startups work separately? Well, I wouldn't say they necessarily work separately. 42:13 [clears throat] I mean, uh, however, one of my recommendation is startups should engage with the value chain, yeah, as soon as possibleYeah. So I wouldn't necessarily say they all work separately. 42:27 They do-- There are some who are very successful and engage on, along the value chain. Uh, that's what, uh, that's what I would answer. 42:35 But those who are only in a bilateral relationship, yeah, the speed to market will take a longer time than expected. Mm-hmm. Uh, there's a good question here from Andrew Powell. 42:44 You do not just need a good product; you need social license to operate. What is being done by this sector to achieve that? Who's gonna put their hand up for that one? Well, I-I'll, uh, just kickstart that one. 43:00 Uh, one of the points is with regards to single cell protein or, or single cells, whether it's fungi, yeast, et cetera, is you can, if you do it right, get a very low carbon footprint of close to one, 43:17 which is significantly lower than animal protein and current plant protein, like soybean meal. And I think that, together with the fact that it utilizes less land 43:32 and less water, makes this sector quite relevant, particularly in the face of climate change and growing populations. But I come back to the fact that we still need to solve the taste, texture, and cost issue. Mm-hmm. 43:48 It's not a technological issue, it's actually how do you produce it at scale consistently at a lower cost. And I think there are companies who are in that direction and gonna make it happen. 44:02 We're gonna, um, wrap up with a, a systems view, um, 'cause it's going to take more than just great ingredients to create a future, um, ready food system. 44:10 So Kelly, I know you're a big proponent of aligning startups, corporates, governments, and even farmers. Um, what are the biggest cultural or structural barriers holding that back? No, absolutely. 44:22 And, uh, I think we touched on it, um, a few times, um, uh, during this seminar. Every step of the food supply chain does need to be aligned if we're gonna end up in mass market food production. 44:33 Um, and, and all the-- but the different bodies, I think they're-- there is a different culture in each of them, and there are different goals for each of them and a different language within each of them. 44:44 And startups talk the language of science. They need to be able to communicate that to non-scientists. 44:49 Corporates are protective of their brands, and they need to show that there's value for the consumers and value for their shareholders. 44:56 The farmers, I mean, they are the existing food supply chain, and they need to show how they are integrated into the everything. And similarly, governments, you know, th-their interest in being reelected. 45:06 So, so the key thing is not just connecting the bodies, but connecting the individuals in those bodies that have a passion, they have a commitment, they want to engage, and they're willing to actually work within their own institutions to actually make something happen. 45:24 If you can connect those individuals, and all change occurs through connections of individuals across these different bodies, uh, in the right way, then I think change can happen. 45:34 Um, but you need those change champions within each body really connected. It doesn't happen across the bodies themselves. I can see that, uh, this next question was actually asked by someone in the audience anyway. 45:45 But, um, Roland, when evaluating new ingredient platforms, how does Danone approach the balance between, uh, internal development and strategic partnerships? 45:57 Uh, so yeah, we work on a so-called, uh, I mean, at least I call it like that, a hybrid model. We think that one doesn't exclude the other, of course. And, uh, we collaborate with academics, 46:12 with larger ingredient suppliers, with many platforms, uh, especially with Mista. I mean, we try to be present, uh, as much as possible on all stages. 46:23 And we think that, uh, the probability that we are the more and more present, the probability that we meet the, the right player is higher. 46:33 So we try to, you know, statistically and try to find the right one by, uh, gathering more and more, uh, partners and, uh, collaborations. Mm-hmm. 46:45 Um, Raman, um, from the audience has ha- said, "Nick, have you had anyone from Corn on a panel or would you?" Uh, the answer to that is yes, we've had people from Corn, um, on here before. 46:54 Um, so yeah, that answers that one. Um, now someone's already mentioned Make America, uh, Healthy Again, that mindset. 47:02 Charles, um, I know you're a proponent of that, um, moving big food away from carbon-heavy, ultra-processed products. What does that transformation really look like, um, from inside the system? 47:14 Yeah, I know, um, Celine, there's some, some really good points earlier on, uh, with regards to that wider MAHA movement and how it spills over in, in Europe. 47:22 Uh, and, and to Kelly's point, I, I think this is somewhat happening already with big retail working with startups. 47:29 Uh, we are, for instance, already in business with both Aldi and, and Lidl, and I would say time to get our product on shelves is actually quite, quite short. 47:37 So I think that MAHA mindset is slowly but surely coming to both big food and big retail. The way it works, uh, in, in my view, is that big food should be the one driving the change. 47:51 They know about evolving customer needs. Uh, especially in the US right now, there's just a huge protein craze. Anything needs to be protein reinforced. 47:59 Uh, we talked about, you know, ultra-processed, uh, backlash as well. So people are-- wanna eat, uh, better ingredients, which are less transformed and whole food ingredients. 48:09 So my, my view of that transformation is then big food and big retail needs the one, uh, leading that change, uh, because they're the ones facing the customers, and they know what their customers want. Mm-hmm. 48:22 And Charles, you could probably answer this one actually. There's a growing concern around Europe about losing, uh, sugar processing capacity, even though sugar is critical, um, to biomass fermentation. 48:31 Is there a danger that we could be overlooking essential bio-economy infrastructure?Yeah, that-that's, that's a really good question. Um, it's true, uh, plants in... 48:41 I'm, I'm talking for Europe right now, but plants in Austria, the Czech Republic, uh, quite a few in France actually have recently closed down. 48:48 So while, you know, there may be some actual industrial over capacity and there may need to be some industrial restructuring, uh, um, this reduction and those sugar mills actually shutting down have led to actual production volume reduction, while sugar, and again, speaking for, for my own, uh, company, uh, in this case, sucrose, uh, is, is really the white gold of, uh, carbon sources for fermentation. 49:14 So I think it is important that countries and maybe the EU as a whole understand that access to feedstock is effectively the number one criteria for building biomanufacturing capacity in any country, um, especially when we talk about, uh, protein dependency. 49:31 Um, I, I indeed think that this whole notion of white gold is maybe overlooked by, uh, both policymakers but also, uh, operators as well. 49:42 And I'm thinking about sugar produ-producers themselves who may underestimate how they could better valorize, uh, that output today, uh, and maybe, you know, um, better restructure that, that industrial footprint of theirs. 49:56 Mm-hmm. And this, this question, um, from the audience, I'm not sure who it's from. Um, when discussing biomass fermentation, finding a suitable substrate for our microbes can be a significant challenge. 50:06 How substantial is that challenge if biomass fermentation is adopted on a large scale? Who's gonna answer that one? So maybe I can start. 50:19 From this point of view, I mean, uh, carbon dioxide and, and, uh, is available everywhere, and, uh, so the problem of feedstock doesn't exist, uh, lit... 50:29 Uh, and that's one, one solution from, uh, uh, in terms of feedstocks. 50:34 If, if you're in a l- either in, in a situation where the feedstock is plentiful or the, or the feedstock is readily available, that is, uh, yeah, just one of the key, uh, key barriers to entry. 50:45 But, um, but yeah, from, from Arborea's point of view, yeah, wherever there's carbon dioxide and natural sunlight, you have the feedstocks. Mm-hmm. So I can, I can maybe add on that. Sorry, my camera died. 50:57 Don't know why. Oh. And, uh, so it... I cannot, yeah, whatever. Uh, Danone, we have also a lot of side streams, right? 51:05 We have, uh, all the side streams from Alpro, from Silk, so that's, uh, plant-based side streams, but also we can feed some microorganism with, uh, milk side streams, which, uh, and yeah, some startups are busy with that. 51:21 We are of course exploring them and see if it makes any sense. So yeah, we are busy with that as well. Mm-hmm. Uh, and on that note, um, actually Roland, this is probably a question for Kelly. 51:32 Um, Zhao Costa has asked: How do you reuse the waste or non-wanted streams in your process? 51:38 Actually, uh, there, there isn't any waste, um, because once you pull out the protein, for example, from microalgae, you then have a bioactive nutrient concentrate that can actually be used to replenish soil microbiomes or can be used in, uh, natural supplements. 51:53 Uh, virtually everything inside the microalgae has got some nutritional use, uh, or some valorization, so that's the beauty of it. They really are superfoods. 52:02 So, um, so no, um, and, and Roland's point actually, uh, I always would say that a, a side stream is just the, um, application knowledge waiting to happen really [chuckles] 'cause it's really about, um, th- they're all usable if you, if you have the knowledge to be able to use them. 52:18 But, uh, yeah, certainly in the terms of microalgae, it's pretty obvious, uh, all the different, uh, side streams have useful- Yeah. We've got too many questions here. I'm not gonna be able to get them through them all. 52:29 Um, if I've got time, I will come to, uh, one or two more. Um, Sean, um, Sean Philippe, the UK government, uh, just, just launched this good food cycle. 52:38 Um, so how do biomass-based platforms fit into that vision, and what policy tools do we need to, to accelerate progress? Yeah. Thanks, Nick. 52:47 Um, so the good fu- food cycle was, uh, launched a few weeks ago, a couple of weeks ago now, um, and that's part of, uh, the UK National Food Strategy. Um, so there's some, some kind of key pillars around that. 53:00 They want healthier and more fruitable foods, uh, they want growth, they want sustainable supply chains, and they want, uh, a vibrant food culture, as they, as they call it. 53:10 Um, so that's, that's very broad, but it, it kind of paints the picture in, in a direction that the UK government wants to see our food system go in. 53:17 Um, they do mention alternative proteins within the, the good food cycle in terms of the UK being a particularly strong place, um, due to some, due to its strong, uh, research institutions and some of its manufacturing cap- capability to, to build on, on the alternative protein ecosystem that already exists here and particular with, uh, with biomass, um, being particularly strong here as well. 53:41 The, the other aspect is that they reference the, um, the industrial strategy in the UK that was also recently published, which specifically allocates, um, funding towards, uh, engineering biology, and biomass products are, are a part of that. 53:57 So there's particularly, um, around a hundred and eighty million, uh, pounds, which is, is gonna be dedicated to infrastructure across, uh, many different sectors, but one of which will be food engineering biology, um, and biomass, um, foods will, will, will come under that. 54:14 So, so I think there's, there's strong signals from the UK government. We need to make it a reality. 54:20 Um, but yeah, I think there's, there's more and more acceptance that, um, it, it, it acknowledges in the good food cycle that seventy percent, um, of UK land is dedicated to agriculture in one way or another, um, but it's also one of the biggest drivers of biodiversity loss and, and things that we know is the case globally as well. 54:38 So, um, so yeah, I think they are acknowledging thatUm, the biomass and products and then alternative proteins will generally have to be a part of that, that solution. Um, I'm gonna ask this question from Raman. 54:50 I'm not sure who's gonna answer it, but, uh, he'll hunt me down on LinkedIn, um, if I don't. 54:54 Why are we ignoring the largest flexitarian market, India, with over a billion people who would eat meat but voluntarily abstain for various reasons? I'm not gonna... I don't know who's gonna answer that one. 55:06 I can, I can take this one, Nick. Um, uh, well, I don't think we're ignoring it. 55:10 Um, we are actually actively, uh, working in that region just because it is, um, very, you know, sugar abundant, uh, almost an oversupply of, of sugar. 55:21 Uh, and with actual protein scarcity or, or, uh, or some missing gap in the wider protein value chain. Um, so I think it is a very credible market, uh, with potential huge demand. 55:34 And as you already pointed out, uh, maybe the biggest flexitarian, uh, market of them all. Um, so I think it, it actually makes sense just like... 55:42 I, I think it's true for industrial biotech and as it would be for other parts, we need the, the, um, the wider ecosystem to scale up together. 55:51 So if we go out there and start producing, someone needs to be, uh, commercializing and doing the, the gospel or, or the education of what mycoprotein actually is and what actually, uh, you know, all the, all the benefits associated with it. 56:04 So, um, I think, um, you know, i-in, in, uh, in a nutshell, I think it's a very promising, uh, geography, if not one of the most, uh, promising ones. But, um, it needs to be a concerted effort here. Mm-hmm. 56:17 And Kelly, you've already said that your system can be deployed anywhere where there's barren land, so. Uh, yeah, absolutely. 56:24 So, uh, and I mean, if there is an abundant feedstock or a side stream, absolutely that can be used. But yeah, absolutely, the Arborea technology, uh, can convert barren land into effectively farmland. 56:37 So, and to answer one of the previous questions, some of the byproducts can go back into, uh, farmland to actually make s- uh, s- uh, fertile land more fertile. So it's a complete circular argument. 56:48 And even to generate the carbon dioxide in the first place, uh, uh, agri- waste agricultural crops can be burned to generate the carbon dioxide and captured. 56:57 So, um, it, it, it really is about looking at the entire economy, helping the, the farming system, helping, uh, the local use of side streams, uh, as well. But, um, absolutely, yeah. 57:10 Um, it, the, the technology can be deployed at any scale and it's modular even on a, on a rooftop. Okay. We're gonna, um, wrap up now. Before we close, though, let's just do a quick round robin. 57:21 Um, this is a question for all of you. If you had one piece of advice for food companies looking to engage with biomass-based innovation over the next three or four years, what would it be? 57:29 Um, Karim, I'll come to you first. My advice would be actually there are many more consumers out there who want to reduce meat intake but still retain the meat experience, and that is an untouched market. 57:44 I think what we've done is we've touched the one percent, but not the thirty-five percent that's sitting there. Mm-hmm. So engage early. Engage early. Okay. Céline? 57:56 Uh, my piece of in- of advice for large corporates is to really have R&D and marketing and brands talk to each other early, uh, and avoid having R&D, uh, clear an ingredient on their own without any buy-in from the brands. 58:10 So talk to each other. Mm-hmm. And Charles? Um, at the risk of stating the obvious, I would say, uh, just make sure you can compete on price. I think a lot of focus has been on taste, which I think is very true. 58:24 Uh, but I think price is a, is a massive argument here. So do the, 58:29 do the stress testing, do all the sensitivity analysis that you need to, to do to make sure that you can get a product at price parity, uh, with the relevant alternative, if not cheaper. Mm-hmm. 58:42 Yeah, that's a very good point. Um, let's go to a large food company. Roland? Yeah. So it's exactly the same remark that Charles. 58:50 So despite all the effort, sometimes, I mean, you can have a great protein, but if the price parity is not there, and I don't say price parity with milk proteins, which is not that hard, but sometimes we are asked to have a price parity with, uh, plant proteins. 59:08 And, you know, soy is, uh, very cheap. 59:11 So there, uh, the challenge is huge sometimes to push these new players in because, yeah, at the end, uh, yeah, it's more expensive than soy or pea or whatever, and then we are stuck there. Mm-hmm. 59:24 It's, uh- Jean-Philippe?... very challenging. Very challenging indeed. Jean-Philippe? 59:30 Um, my suggestion would be to also engage with some of the, the, the hubs, the research institutions that are now like looking into, into these novel food areas. 59:39 Um, I think speaking from, from us and our center, um, we have, we have a lot of very interesting, uh, yeah, innovations and, and scale up projects with expert, um, academics that, that are going ahead. 59:53 So, so I think even engaging your own TD teams on, on those things I think can, can lead some interesting findings. Yeah. Well, we started with Kelly, so we're gonna end with Kelly. You've got the final word, sir. Okay. 1:00:05 Well, well basically you, you need to have excellent food prototypes so people can see, touch, and f- feel what the technology can do. 1:00:11 And then we need to make sure that every part of the supply chain can benefit in some way or another, all the way from farmer to consumer with that technology and the, and everyone in between. 1:00:21 Otherwise, it just doesn't happen. If part of the chain breaks, it, it doesn't turn into mass production. Thank you very much for that. That's all we have time for today. Um, I thought that was a really good discussion. 1:00:32 Lots of, uh, reminders that the future of food might not grow in fields, but in fermenters, photobioreactors, and precision designed biomass systems. 1:00:39 A huge thank you to all of our speakers for sharing their expertise and experiences. That's, uh, Jean, Jean-Philippe, Céline, um, Roland, Karim, Charles, and Kelly. 1:00:49 And special thanks to Kelly for the presentation at the start and to Arborea for being our sponsor today and making all of this happen. 1:00:55 We hope today's session gave you plenty to think about, uh, and who knows, even more to, to act on. 1:01:00 Um, if I didn't get a chance to ask your question, there were lots of them, apologies, but feel free to reach out to our panelists on LinkedIn, where I'm sure they won't mind you continuing the discussion. 1:01:09 Um, now shameless plug time. Don't forget to check out Protein Production Technology International, our quarterly magazine, um, and our daily news site for all of the latest insights across the alt protein space. 1:01:19 Our Q2 25, um, edition is out now and has already been broken our previous record for unique monthly, um, views, which is under thirty-nine thousand people logging on in July alone. 1:01:31 Our Q3 2025 edition will be published on the 17th of September and will feature an article based on today's discussion. 1:01:39 We'll be back next month on the 28th of August with another webinar, From Tech to Table: Making Plant Protein Work for Real Food and Real Consumers, and that's in partnership with Happy Plant Protein. 1:01:49 And you can head over to our website right now to register for that one. Until then, thank you for joining us. See you soon. 1:01:56 [outro music] Thank you for listening to the Protein Production Technology International podcast. 1:02:02 We hope you gained valuable insights and knowledge about the innovative technologies and practices transforming how we produce protein. 1:02:09 Don't forget to subscribe to PPTI Magazine and follow us on social media to stay up to date with the latest news and updates. Stay tuned for more exciting episodes.